Here is an idea....
Use a pump that has flat panels on all four sides.
Take a few big rectangular ratty porcelain signs and chop them into new panels for the pump.
Better yet, use non oil co signs...or a mix of several signs.
Perferated "Crisco" can for a globe, pair of vise grips for the reset handle, old garden hose, and the rattiest, beat to h*ll nozzle you can find.
Put a few bullet holes in the faces, maybe a few more in the panels. Use unrestored misc. stainless parts of various pumps
for the exterior, so no paint would be needed.... the old GOC pumps would work good.
Maybe not such a bad idea if all you have is the base, frame, top of that cabinet.
I know it is politically incorrect but I had to do one with a Shell globe on top, it just looked too good on that top!!!!!