There is some postings on this website for some suggested paint colors for POLLY. Check out
www.bobs-garage.com, supposedly the paint he sells are matched to original paint codes, chips based on a book, catalog he has for the different major gas companies, not sure if that's all or partially true. Give him a call and he can explain it better. Nevertheless, I got the green paint from him, for my two Polly Gas pumps, see pics on showcase forum "POLLY GAS Pumps Southwest Model 812), the green matches the decals very well. There are so many pictures of the pumps restored using different versions of green for POLLY GAS, non-metalic, metalic, light green, medium green, etc. It's a matter of tastes. They all look good. Good-luck. Post pics when your done.