Thanks for all the comments guys, I'll probably just do it all silver cause that's the way I've seen the most of them done.
Travis, You mentioned that you change decals and globes every couple of months. When you change the decals have you ever had a chunk of paint come off the pump?
Never had a painted pump - all are powder coated....
This new tokheim 39 will be painted, and I will start going to sign shops and getting big car sign magnets to put the new stickers on. Then switch them with magnets.
One member of this board said to glue screw heads into the corners of the magnet signs and then they will look like bolt on signs...