I read this whole thread with interest. I would have to say T Way has come closest to my way of thinking.
I agree that reproductions are necessary and for the stated reasons - outdoor display, restaurant and rec room "themes", originals are wasted here - and nowhere near as available or affordable. People see these reproductions, and maybe it piques their interest in the original side of the hobby.
One can also use original artwork on reproduction globes, decals, etc., to finish a project pump that would otherwise not be possible for the collector of modest means.
But passing off a reproduction as original in a business transaction is fraud.
Knowingly passing off a reproduction as original, in your house or garage, to your friends, neighbors, visitors, co-workers..., well, that is another thing altogether... but up to that person.
Know anybody that wears a fake Rolex? Why would they do that? Same reason, I would think...
That's not the sort of "hobbyist" we're talking about on this board, I don't think.
But hey - if you are a purist, own nothing but originals, and wouldn't have it any other way, well, that's great too! You're a gatekeeper. Every endeavor need experts and purists.
I would guess that most petro collector fall between the two extremes. I know I do.
Just my opinion.
[This message has been edited by silent chief (edited 08-18-2007).]
