Paint it. All this patina talk don't fly guys. Rust, holes, broken glass etc don't look good especially when you are showing it to a non petro person. He is standing there wondering what in the hell is so neat about a bunch of rust on an old gas pump.They were all painted when they left the factory and repainted many times after when they faded or changed brands. You patina guys have it all wrong. I always thought patina was on wood, when did rust get into fashion as patina?