Hershey is MUCH larger, has very close parking for $10 (I don't think it's more than that), and no admittance charge. Last year at Hershey the ATM's (only two of them) were out of cash on Wed, and they were not allowing the vendors to use ATM cash machines. I can cover Carlisle in one day, but you would have a difficult time covering Hershey in a single day. It can be a challenge finding close parking at Carlisle, and there is an admittance fee per person. I have found great deals at both, but I vote Hershey hands down as my show of choice. Brady