Welcome to oldgas.... I'm glad to see the Colorado ranks getting stronger.
My first pump was also a Tokheim 39A (shorty) It's a simple pump to work on, and it also has a lot of reproduction parts available. I'm guessing, from the numbers, that yours is also a 39A. Which would have lift off doors, instead of hinged doors.
Here is a pic of my 96C which is painted in Chevron Supreme colors. As for the colors that you have described, I think that Chevron is correct. Although the Supreme Grade pumps were usually all blue, most pumps started their life from the factory as red. Some Chevron independants painted only the doors of their Supreme pumps, in the blue color. Which is opposite of what yours is.
Sometimes, people just painted their pump whatever colors they wanted when they went into private use. As you begin your restoration, you might want to strip the paint off slowly. Maybe with a rag, paint stripper, and a lot of elbow grease. Some times this will let the pump tell you it's own story, as the original colors and decals might show up. (See "Another Mystery Decal")
http://www.oldgas.com/shoptalk/ubb/Forum1/HTML/006446.html Good luck. Keep us posted. And drop an "e" if I can be of any help... If you need help posting pics, send them to me, and I'll post them for you.
[This message has been edited by Thunder (edited 10-14-2005).]