Is that center piece rubber? I would say it is a station lighter top but it has been so long sense I seen the two pumps with station lighters. I do not remember the screws. I have been told by one than one person that there were three tops for these pumps, one with no globe, one with globe holder and one for station lighter. I also had some one tell me there were only two tops so maybe some one else can help out here. If you take that cap off and get a globe holder for a Tokheim 39 it will bolt right in place useing those screw holes.

I likeShell [Linked Image from imagizer.imageshack.com]